Skip to content

Buying Guides and Comparisons

Best AI Receptionist? 15 Questions That Decide It

Fifteen questions to put to any AI receptionist vendor, what good and bad answers sound like, a scoring sheet and the five must-pass questions. No ranking.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing9 min read

On this page
  1. Why a ranking will not settle it
  2. Calls: questions 1 to 4
  3. Actions: questions 5 to 8
  4. Records and control: questions 9 to 11
  5. Data and compliance: questions 12 and 13
  6. Proof and terms: questions 14 and 15
  7. Score the answers
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. References
Buying Guides and Comparisons: Best AI Receptionist? 15 Questions That Decide It5: FTC enforcement actions against deceptive AI claims announced on a single day in 2024BUYING GUIDES AND COMPARISONSBest AI Receptionist? 15Questions That Decide It5FTC enforcement actions against deceptive AI claims announced on asingle day in 2024AssistCallInsightsBuying Guides and Comparisons: Best AI Receptionist? 15 Questions That Decide It5: FTC enforcement actions against deceptive AI claims announced on a single day in 2024BUYING GUIDES AND COMPARISONSBest AI Receptionist?15 Questions ThatDecide It5FTC enforcement actions againstdeceptive AI claims announced on asingle day in 2024AssistCall
Figure source: Federal Trade Commission, 2024[1]

Key takeaways

  • No ranking has tested your calls; fifteen written questions and a test on a slice of your real calls will.
  • Five questions are must-pass: unanswered transfers, the first ten seconds, bookings, taking your data with you, and testing on your own calls.
  • Good answers are specific and can be shown; bad answers are absolute, such as handles everything or syncs with everything.
  • Compliance answers belong in writing: recording consent, business associate agreements, supervised legal intake[2][3][4].
  • Run the money question yourself first; in the roofing example, about $19,500 of contract work a month rides on missed calls.

Why a ranking will not settle it

No ranking list can tell you which AI receptionist is best for an orthodontist with a busy front desk, or for a roofer who answers the phone from a ladder. Best depends on your calls: how many, when they arrive, what they need, and what happens when one goes wrong. The product that tops a list may lose badly on the three call types that pay your bills.

Treat marketing claims with care, too. In 2024 the FTC announced five enforcement actions against deceptive AI claims and schemes under Operation AI Comply, and its chair said there is no AI exemption from the laws on the books[1]. Claims about how human a product sounds or how much it will earn you are still claims. The questions below turn them into answers you can check.

Send all fifteen questions in writing before any demo. How plainly a vendor answers on paper is a fair preview of how it will answer when something goes wrong later. Each question comes with what a good answer and a bad answer tend to sound like.

Calls: questions 1 to 4

1. Which calls will it handle from start to finish, and which go to a person? Good answer: a specific list drawn from your call types, with the hand-offs named, such as emergencies, complaints and anything that needs a license. Bad answer: it handles everything. No receptionist, human or software, should handle everything.

2. What happens when a transfer is not answered? Good answer: you choose the fallback, such as a second person, a detailed message or a callback slot, and the caller is told what happens next. Bad answer: it goes to your voicemail. That is the problem you started with, plus extra steps.

3. How does it handle names, numbers and addresses it might mishear? Good answer: it reads them back, spells names, repeats numbers digit by digit and confirms by text or email. Errors also cluster by speaker. In one peer-reviewed study of five commercial recognition systems, 23% of recordings of Black speakers came back with a word error rate above 0.5, the level the researchers treated as unusable, against 1.6% of recordings of white speakers[5]. Bad answer: a near-perfect accuracy figure with no source and no read-back.

Recordings with an unusable transcript (word error rate above 0.5), five commercial systemsAverage across the five systems, from matched interview recordings.
Recordings with an unusable transcript (word error rate above 0.5), five commercial systemsComparison. Black speakers: 23%; White speakers: 1.6%.23%Black speakersBlack speakers: 23%1.6%White speakersWhite speakers: 1.6%Recordings with an unusable transcript (word error rate above 0.5), five commercial systemsComparison. Black speakers: 23%; White speakers: 1.6%.23%Black speakersBlack speakers: 23%1.6%White speakersWhite speakers: 1.6%

Source: Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, via PubMed Central, 2020[5]

Show the data
ItemValue
Black speakers23%
White speakers1.6%

4. What does the caller hear in the first ten seconds? Good answer: your business name, a plain statement that they have reached the business's automated receptionist, a recording notice if you record, and a quick way to a person. Bad answer: callers will never know. If that is the pitch, ask what it says when a caller asks outright whether they are talking to a real person, and have the vendor play you that answer.

Actions: questions 5 to 8

5. Where does a booking land, and what stops a double booking? Good answer: a named calendar, slot rules you control (hours, durations, buffers), a check at the moment of booking, the date read back to the caller, and a text or email confirming it. Bad answer: it syncs with everything. Ask them to show a booking appear where your staff actually look, during the demo.

6. Can it act on our own systems during a call? Good answer: a precise description, such as webhooks that post call data to a URL you choose for tools like Zapier to pick up, and API actions that look something up in your own system during the call, such as whether an order has shipped. Bad answer: native integration with every app, with no list. Ask whether webhooks are signed so you can verify where they came from; an unsigned webhook will accept fake call data from anyone who finds the address.

7. What can it send to callers, and what consent does that need? Good answer: texts tied to the call, such as confirmations, with clear rules for anything outbound. Since the FCC's 2024 declaratory ruling, outbound calls made with an AI-generated voice fall under the TCPA's artificial-voice rules, so prior express consent comes first[6]. A vendor offering automatic callbacks should show you where each person's consent is captured and stored. Bad answer: it can ring all your old leads tomorrow. The real estate site covers the rules in AI voice calls and the TCPA.

8. What does it do with a call it should not handle? Good answer: it recognizes the categories you list, such as a gas smell, chest pain or a caller in danger, gives the instruction you wrote, and transfers or pages a person at once. Bad answer: the AI will figure it out. Emergencies are written rules, not improvisation.

Records and control: questions 9 to 11

9. What do I get after every call? Good answer: a recording, a full transcript, a summary with the details pulled out, a contact record and a notification, all in one place. Bad answer: a short email with a phone number in it. Ask for a real summary from your demo call and hand it to a colleague. If they cannot act on it without listening to the recording, the summary is not doing its job.

10. Can I step into a call while it is happening? Good answer: yes: listen in, whisper to steer it, or take the call over. You will use it most in the first few weeks. Bad answer: you can review the recordings later. Later is too late for the call that is going wrong right now.

11. Who owns the call data, and how do I take it with me? Good answer: you do; contacts export to CSV, recordings and transcripts can be downloaded, and you know how long they are kept. Bad answer: leaving requires a support ticket and a negotiation. Ask for a sample export during the trial, not after you have decided to leave.

Data and compliance: questions 12 and 13

12. How does recording work in a state that needs everyone's consent? Good answer: a recording announcement you can word yourself, played before the caller says anything that matters. One-party consent is enough under the federal wiretap law[7], but Washington's statute needs the consent of all participants and accepts an announcement only if the announcement is recorded too[2]. Bad answer: recording is always on and legal everywhere.

13. Will you sign the agreements my profession requires? For medical and dental offices, the good answer is a business associate agreement, signed before any protected health information flows, because HIPAA expects the vendor's safeguards to be promised in writing[3]; avaintake.com on AI phone agents and HIPAA goes further. A plain ‘not yet’ is also a usable answer, as long as you hear it before you sign. For law firms, ABA Formal Opinion 506 accepts intake by trained, supervised nonlawyers if each caller still gets a real opportunity to speak with a lawyer[4]. Ask to see the intake questions and the route to an attorney. Bad answer: we are fully compliant, with nothing in writing.

Proof and terms: questions 14 and 15

14. Can we test it on our own calls before committing? Good answer: yes, by forwarding a slice of real calls, such as after-hours or overflow, with full transcripts so you can score the result. Bad answer: the demo shows what it can do. The demo shows what it does on their script. For a two-week version of that test with a scorecard, see is an AI receptionist worth it.

15. What would it recover for us, using our numbers? Good answer: the vendor works through your call log, missed share and job value with you, and labels assumptions as assumptions. Bad answer: customers typically triple their bookings. Run the arithmetic yourself before the call. The example below is a fictional roofing contractor whose owner answers the phone from the job site.

ExampleExample: missed calls at a fictional roofing contractor
Example: worked figures
InputExample
Calls per week30
Calls that go unanswered (%)20%
Unanswered calls from new customers (%)50%
Share of answered new callers who sign15%
Typical roofing job$10,000
Unanswered calls a month26
From new customers13
Bookings that would have followed1.9
Monthly value at risk$19,485

How it is worked out: Calls a week × 4.33 weeks × unanswered share × new-customer share × booking rate × average value.

Assumptions

  • Typical job of $10,000, the American Housing Survey median homeowner spend on roofing projects in 2021 to 2023; compare it with your own average contract.[8]
  • Thirty calls a week, one in five missed while the crew is on a roof, half of the missed callers new customers and 15% of those signing: invented inputs, to be replaced from your own phone report.

Example only: about $19,500 of roofing work a month sits behind missed calls in this model, or roughly two jobs. Enter your own call counts to see your figure.

Contract terms belong in the same question. Ask for the notice period, what happens to your phone number if you leave, and whether you can start month to month. A vendor that is confident about question 14 rarely needs a long lock-in.

Score the answers

Example scoring sheet; adjust the weights to your own risks
AreaQuestionsExample weightMust-pass
Calls1 to 425 of 1002 and 4
Actions5 to 825 of 1005
Records and control9 to 1120 of 10011
Data and compliance12 and 1315 of 100Both, for regulated businesses
Proof and terms14 and 1515 of 10014
Example: running the 15 questions across three vendors
  • Your team
  • Caller
  • SI Employee
  • System
  1. 01Your team

    Shortlist three vendors

    Rule out any that cannot meet your industry's rules before a demo.

  2. 02Your team

    Send questions in writing

    Ask for written answers to all fifteen; vague replies are data too.

  3. 03Caller

    Call each demo yourself

    Use your own call types, including the awkward ones.

  4. 04SI Employee

    Handles your test calls

    Books, transfers or takes messages under your draft rules.

  5. 05System

    Records land for review

    Recording, transcript and summary to check against what you said.

  6. 06Your team

    Score and decide

    Must-pass questions first, then the weighted score.

Example process for a small business; plan on about two weeks from shortlist to decision.

Score the must-pass questions first. A vendor that fails question 2, 4, 5, 11 or 14 is out regardless of the rest, because each of those failures leaves a caller stranded, misled or double-booked, or leaves you locked in. Then weight the rest by your own risks: a law firm weights question 13 heavily, a restaurant weights question 5, a plumber weights question 8.

The family law intake example shows several of these answered in practice: conflict-check names captured first, consultations booked, urgent matters sent to an on-call attorney. For the trade-offs you accept with any vendor, read AI receptionist pros and cons, and if you are also comparing message-taking services, choosing an AI answering service has a scoring sheet built for that.

Put the same fifteen questions to AssistCall as to everyone else. A product sold as an SI Employee should have plain answers to all of them, including the uncomfortable ones. Our answer to question 13 today: business associate agreements are planned, not available, so medical practices should keep patient details off the line for now. How an AI receptionist works shows where caller details go during and after a call, which is what this question is really about.

Frequently asked questions

Which AI receptionist is best for a small business?

The one that passes your must-pass questions on your own calls. Rankings rarely test the call types that matter to a specific business, so shortlist three products and put the same questions and test calls to each.

Should I trust top-ten lists and review sites?

Use them to build a shortlist, not to decide. Some lists are paid placements, and none of them called your phone line. Written answers and a test on your own calls are better evidence.

How many vendors should I compare?

Three is usually enough. Fewer leaves no real comparison; more and the testing time gets out of hand for a small business.

Which question rules out the most vendors?

Usually question 2, what happens when a transfer is not answered, or question 14, testing on your own calls. Vague answers to either are a strong hint of problems after you sign.

Do I need all fifteen if my business is very small?

Send all fifteen in writing; it costs the vendor a few minutes. If your own time is short, the five must-pass questions in the scoring sheet cover the failures that hurt most.

References

  1. Federal Trade Commission (2024). FTC Announces Crackdown on Deceptive AI Claims and Schemes (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. Washington State Legislature (2026). RCW 9.73.030: Intercepting, recording, or divulging private communication; consent required (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 45 CFR 164.502: Uses and disclosures of protected health information, general rules (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. American Bar Association Standing Committee on Ethics and Professional Responsibility (2023). ABA Formal Opinion 506: Responsibilities Regarding Nonlawyer Assistants (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, via PubMed Central (2020). Racial disparities in automated speech recognition (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Federal Communications Commission (2024). Declaratory Ruling FCC 24-17: Implications of Artificial Intelligence Technologies on Protecting Consumers from Unwanted Robocalls and Robotexts (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (2026). 18 U.S. Code 2511: Interception and disclosure of wire, oral, or electronic communications prohibited (opens in a new tab) ↑

  8. U.S. Census Bureau and U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (2023). Home Improvements (2023 American Housing Survey infographic) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

Meet your SI Employee.

Book a short demo. We walk through calls like yours and show what your SI Employee would answer, book and follow up.

Book a demo