Skip to content

Buying Guides and Comparisons

Call Center vs Answering Service: Which Do You Need?

Call center or answering service? Compare scale, staffing math, billing and scripting depth, with an Erlang C table showing when dedicated agents pay off.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing8 min read

On this page
  1. Two businesses that share a phone line and little else
  2. The staffing math that separates them
  3. How each one bills, and what that rewards
  4. Scripting depth and decision rights
  5. Sizing your own line
  6. What your phone work adds up to
  7. Where software sits between them
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. References
Buying Guides and Comparisons: Call Center vs Answering Service: Which Do You Need?60-70%: of operating costs in most call centers go on capacity, mainly staff, per a widely cited reviewBUYING GUIDES AND COMPARISONSCall Center vs AnsweringService: Which Do You Need?60-70%of operating costs in most call centers go oncapacity, mainly staff, per a widely cited reviewAssistCallInsightsBuying Guides and Comparisons: Call Center vs Answering Service: Which Do You Need?60-70%: of operating costs in most call centers go on capacity, mainly staff, per a widely cited reviewBUYING GUIDES AND COMPARISONSCall Center vsAnswering Service:Which Do You Need?60-70%of operating costs in most callcenters go on capacity, mainly staff,per a widely cited reviewAssistCall
Figure source: Noah Gans, Ger Koole and Avishai Mandelbaum (INFORMS), 2003[1]

Key takeaways

  • An answering service sells coverage from a shared team; a call center sells capacity from agents trained on your business and systems.
  • Contact-center sites are far larger: about 111 employees each in 2023, against about 40 at answering services[2].
  • Queueing math explains the split: at six calls in the busiest hour, two dedicated agents would sit idle about 80% of the time.
  • Per-minute billing rewards short calls; per-hour or per-seat billing rewards steady, predictable volume. Match the model to your calls.
  • Size your own line from the busiest hour and the length of a real call before asking either kind of vendor for a quote.

Two businesses that share a phone line and little else

A call center and an answering service both pick up phones on behalf of other companies, and that is about where the resemblance ends. One sells capacity: trained agents who work your customers' requests through to the end, planned and measured by the half hour. The other sells coverage: a shared team that answers for many businesses, takes the message or patches the call through, and moves on to the next client's line.

Even the government counts them separately. In the industry codes the Census Bureau uses, the telephone call center group splits into telephone answering services and telemarketing bureaus and other contact centers[3]. In 2023 there were 1,035 answering service establishments employing 41,582 people, about 40 per site, against 3,106 contact-center establishments employing 344,605, about 111 per site. Fifty-six contact centers had 1,000 or more employees; seven answering services did[2].

Share of establishments by number of employees, 2023Telephone answering services (NAICS 561421) against telemarketing bureaus and other contact centers (561422).
Share of establishments by number of employees, 2023Column chart. Under 20: Answering services 73.2%, Contact centers 56.1%; 20 to 99: Answering services 21.6%, Contact centers 23.1%; 100 to 999: Answering services 4.4%, Contact centers 19%; 1,000 or more: Answering services 0.7%, Contact centers 1.8%.0%20%40%60%80%Under 20 · Answering services: 73.2%73.2%Under 20 · Contact centers: 56.1%56.1%Under 2020 to 99 · Answering services: 21.6%21.6%20 to 99 · Contact centers: 23.1%23.1%20 to 99100 to 999 · Answering services: 4.4%4.4%100 to 999 · Contact centers: 19%19%100 to 9991,000 or more · Answering services: 0.7%0.7%1,000 or more · Contact centers: 1.8%1.8%1,000 or moreShare of establishments by number of employees, 2023Column chart. Under 20: Answering services 73.2%, Contact centers 56.1%; 20 to 99: Answering services 21.6%, Contact centers 23.1%; 100 to 999: Answering services 4.4%, Contact centers 19%; 1,000 or more: Answering services 0.7%, Contact centers 1.8%.0%20%40%60%80%Under 20 · Answering services: 73.2%Under 20 · Contact centers: 56.1%Under 2020 to 99 · Answering services: 21.6%20 to 99 · Contact centers: 23.1%20 to 99100 to 999 · Answering services: 4.4%100 to 999 · Contact centers: 19%100 to9991,000 or more · Answering services: 0.7%1,000 or more · Contact centers: 1.8%1,000 ormore
  • Answering services
  • Contact centers

Source: U.S. Census Bureau, 2023[2]

Show the data
ItemAnswering servicesContact centers
Under 2073.2%56.1%
20 to 9921.6%23.1%
100 to 9994.4%19%
1,000 or more0.7%1.8%

Nearly one contact-center site in five employs 100 people or more, against fewer than one answering service in 20[2]. Scale is not a vanity number here. It decides how each kind of operation staffs its phones, how it bills you and how much it can learn about your business.

The staffing math that separates them

Call centers plan staff with queueing math. The usual target is a service level: the share of calls answered within a set number of seconds, typically 20 or 30[1]. The standard way to turn a call forecast into a head count is the Erlang C formula, adopted widely because it is easy to use, though it assumes callers never hang up while waiting[1]. Run it at small-business volumes and the reason answering services exist becomes obvious.

Example: agents needed to answer 80% of calls within 20 seconds, calculated with the Erlang C formula
Calls in the busiest hourAverage call, including notesAgents neededShare of the hour each agent spends on calls
64 minutes220%
124 minutes327%
305 minutes550%
605 minutes862%
1205 minutes1471%
3005 minutes3083%
6005 minutes5788%

Read the top row first. Example: a business taking six calls in its busiest hour needs two people on the phones to answer most calls within 20 seconds, and each of them spends about 80% of that hour waiting. No small business can carry that for its own line, so answering services pool dozens of clients onto one team and sell each a slice of it. Pooling is the whole economic model; the call-center review by Gans, Koole and Mandelbaum describes how economies of scale let larger pooled systems answer quickly without running agents idle[1].

Now read the bottom rows. At 300 calls an hour, agents are on calls most of the time and a dedicated team can be trained deeply on one client's products without wasting much of its day. That is call-center territory. In most call centers, staff and other capacity costs make up 60% to 70% of operating expenses[1], which is why a call center's price follows its labor: customer service representatives earned a median of $21.53 an hour in 2025 before benefits[4].

How each one bills, and what that rewards

Answering services usually bill by the minute or by the call against a monthly plan. That suits short, unpredictable calls, and it gives the service a reason to keep every call brief. If your calls need a ten-question intake, the meter and your interests pull in opposite directions. Call centers usually bill by agent hour, by seat or by handled contact, often with minimum commitments and paid training time. You pay for idle minutes in a quiet hour, but you get agents who know your products and work inside your systems.

Call center and answering service, side by side
Call centerAnswering service
Built forHundreds or thousands of calls a dayA few to a few dozen calls a day per client
AgentsDedicated or semi-dedicated to your accountShared across many client accounts
BillingAgent hours, seats or handled contactsMinutes or calls against a monthly plan
TrainingWeeks on your products and systemsA script and a reference sheet
SystemsWorks inside your CRM, order or ticket toolsIts own message platform
Typical outcomeRequest resolved, order taken, account changedMessage relayed or call patched through

Typical arrangements; individual providers vary, so confirm each line in the proposal.

Pick the model whose incentive matches your calls. Short, unpredictable calls that end in a message fit per-minute pooling. Long, complex calls arriving at a steady rate fit paid agent hours, because depth is what you are buying. A business with both often splits them: a call center or in-house team for the daytime support queue, an answering service for nights and overflow.

Scripting depth and decision rights

Customer service representatives usually get two to four weeks of on-the-job training, often with an experienced colleague alongside them for the first weeks[4]. A call center can spend that time on your products. An answering service agent may switch between a dozen clients' scripts in an hour, so your script has to fit on one screen and be readable at a glance.

Neither model hands agents much freedom. In O*NET's survey of customer service representatives, 21% said the job gives them a lot of freedom to make decisions without supervision, while 26% said it gives them none[5]. Every decision you want made on the call has to be written down in advance. The real difference is how many decisions you can write down, and how much of your system the agent is allowed to touch. A call center can typically do the following; most answering services cannot:

  • Look up an order, appointment or account in your system and answer from it.
  • Process a return, a change of address or a cancellation while the caller waits.
  • Run outbound campaigns: follow-ups, renewals and win-back calls.
  • Score a sample of every agent's calls and coach on the results.
  • Report answer times and abandonment by the half hour, so you can see the bad hours.

Outbound work brings its own rules. The National Do Not Call Registry held about 258.5 million active phone numbers at the end of September 2025[6], and any call center dialing on your behalf should scrub its lists against it and show you how it records consent.

Sizing your own line

  1. Find your busiest hour

    Take a month of call logs and pick the busiest hour on a normal busy day, not the daily average. Monday mornings and the hour after lunch are common peaks.

  2. Time real calls

    From hello to the end of the notes, for ten ordinary calls. Average them. Most owners guess short.

  3. Decide what must finish on the call

    A booking, an order, a payment, an account change, or only a message. The more that must finish, the more training and system access the agent needs.

  4. Find your row in the table

    As a rule of thumb from the Erlang table: under about ten calls in the peak hour, pooled answering or software; tens of calls, your own staff plus overflow cover; hundreds, a dedicated team in-house or at a call center.

  5. Check what goes out, not just in

    Reminders, follow-ups and sales calls are call-center work, and they come with consent and Do Not Call obligations.

A multi-location business is the usual edge case. Each site alone sits in the top rows of the table, but combined they may reach the middle. That is the argument for one central phone team, covered in the guide to phone coverage across multiple locations and, for medical groups, in the avaintake guide to centralized call centers for multi-location practices.

What your phone work adds up to

Before asking either kind of vendor for a quote, put your own workload into hours. The example below is a fictional four-location dental group that runs its phones from one central team, using the average employer cost for office and administrative staff in health care[7].

ExampleExample: phone workload at a fictional four-location dental group
Example: worked figures
InputExample
Inbound calls per working day160
Minutes per call4
Share of calls counted100%
Employer cost per staff hour$34.59
Calls a month3,472
Staff hours on these calls231
Hours handed off231
Monthly value of that staff time$8,006

How it is worked out: Calls a day × 21.7 working days × minutes per call ÷ 60 × share handled = hours; hours × hourly cost.

Assumptions

  • Employer cost of $34.59 per hour worked for office and administrative staff in health care, June 2026.[7]
  • 160 calls a day at four minutes each, including notes, are invented for a four-location group; use your own logs.

Example only: about 230 staff hours, or roughly $8,000 of staff cost, a month spent on calls in this model.

That is the workload either vendor would be quoting against. In this example it comes to about 230 agent hours a month, or close to 14,000 minutes of talk and notes. A call center prices those hours as seats; an answering service prices the minutes; both prices start from the same log. Knowing the number keeps both quotes honest. The dental front-desk example shows how a single three-chair office splits the same kind of work between staff and outside cover, and how much staff time phone calls take has a worksheet for your own log.

Where software sits between them

Answering software borrows the call center's consistency and the answering service's pay-for-what-you-use logic. An SI Employee answers your forwarded line on the schedule you choose, works only from the instructions you approve, books into a connected calendar or takes a request for staff to confirm, and transfers to the numbers you set when a person is needed. Your team can listen to a call in progress, whisper guidance the caller does not hear, or take the call over. Every call arrives as a summary with the recording and transcript.

For the head-to-head with message-taking services, read SI Employee vs answering service; for live agents against AI answering in general, AI vs live answering service. If your real question is whether outside answering pays at all, start with whether an answering service is worth it, and if the work you want covered is half calls and half admin, answering service vs virtual assistant covers that split.

Frequently asked questions

Is an answering service a type of call center?

In the Census Bureau's industry codes both sit in the telephone call center group, but answering services are counted separately from telemarketing bureaus and contact centers[3]. In practice they sell different things: coverage versus capacity.

How many calls do I need before a call center makes sense?

There is no fixed line, but the Erlang table shows the trade-off: below roughly ten calls in your busiest hour, dedicated agents spend most of their time waiting. Many call centers also set minimum hour or seat commitments.

Can an answering service handle customer support for my product?

For simple, scripted questions, yes. Anything that needs your systems, such as refunds, troubleshooting or account changes, usually needs a dedicated team, in-house or outsourced.

What is a service level, and should I ask for one?

It is the share of calls answered within a target time, which in call centers is typically 20 or 30 seconds[1]. Ask any provider, call center or answering service, for its actual answer times during your busiest hours, not its monthly average.

Do call centers work for small businesses?

They can for predictable bursts, such as a product launch or a seasonal campaign. For an everyday line with a few calls an hour, minimum commitments and training costs usually outweigh the benefit.

References

  1. Noah Gans, Ger Koole and Avishai Mandelbaum (INFORMS) (2003). Telephone Call Centers: Tutorial, Review, and Research Prospects (Manufacturing & Service Operations Management 5(2)) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. U.S. Census Bureau (2023). County Business Patterns 2023, U.S. detail file (NAICS 561421 and 561422) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. U.S. Census Bureau (2017). CBP NAICS 2017 descriptions (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Customer Service Representatives: Occupational Outlook Handbook (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. O*NET OnLine (U.S. Department of Labor, Employment and Training Administration) (2025). 43-4051.00 - Customer Service Representatives (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Federal Trade Commission (2025). FTC Releases Annual Do Not Call Registry Data Book (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Employer Costs for Employee Compensation, Table 4: private industry workers by occupational and industry group, June 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

Meet your SI Employee.

Book a short demo. We walk through calls like yours and show what your SI Employee would answer, book and follow up.

Book a demo