Key takeaways
- Compare the two options against the same list of calls and the same hours, not two price tags.
- In the example, one full-time receptionist costs the employer about $49,800 a year and is at the phone roughly 34 hours a week, averaged over the year.
- Cost per answered call lands between about $1.74 and $4.36 depending on how much of the job is phones; that range decides what software could really replace.
- Fill in the AI side from written quotes: plan, included minutes, overage, set-up and your own review time.
- The numbers leave out walk-ins, relationships and vacancies, so most offices with a counter end up comparing a hybrid, not a swap.
Set the comparison up so it is fair
Owners usually run this comparison backwards: a salary on one side, a monthly software fee on the other, and a quick verdict. The two numbers do not buy the same thing. A receptionist covers certain hours and does more than answer the phone; software covers whatever hours you forward to it and does nothing at the counter. A fair comparison starts from a fixed list of calls and asks what each option costs to handle them.
Example: a fictional independent insurance agency with four licensed agents is open 9 to 5:30, Monday to Friday. It takes about 50 calls a weekday: payments, ID cards, certificates, claims questions, quote requests and agents' existing clients. Another 15 or so arrive each week after 5:30 and on Saturdays and go to voicemail. One full-time receptionist runs the desk. Every number below is built for this example; put your own in as you go.
The human side can be costed to the dollar from public data. The AI side cannot, because vendors price by plan, minutes or calls, so this article gives it as a short worksheet you fill in from quotes.
The human side: one receptionist, costed per hour at the desk
Start with pay. The median receptionist earned $18.27 an hour in May 2025, with the lowest-paid tenth under $13.83 and the highest-paid tenth over $24.01[1]. Where you sit in that range matters more than any other single input, so use your local rate, or the rate on your last offer letter.
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2025[1]
Show the data
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Lowest-paid 10% earn under | $13.83 |
| Median | $18.27 |
| Highest-paid 10% earn over | $24.01 |
Then add what the employer pays on top. For office and administrative support workers, private employers paid $11.51 in benefits for every $25.22 of wages per hour worked in June 2026[2], so benefits add about 46% to the wage. Applied to the median wage, a receptionist costs about $26.60 for each hour actually worked. That ratio already spreads paid leave, insurance, retirement and payroll taxes across working hours.
| Line | Hours or dollars | Where it comes from |
|---|---|---|
| Paid hours | 2,080 | 40 hours a week, 52 weeks |
| Vacation and sick days | minus 144 hours | 11 vacation and 7 sick days, private-industry averages after one year[3] |
| Paid holidays | minus 64 hours | Example: 8 holidays |
| Hours worked | 1,872 | What the employer cost per hour applies to |
| Paid breaks | minus 117 hours | Example: two 15-minute breaks a day with nobody covering |
| Hours at the phone | about 1,755 | About 34 a week averaged over the year |
| Employer cost per hour worked | about $26.60 | $18.27 median wage plus benefits at the office-support ratio[1][2] |
| Annual employer cost | about $49,800 | 1,872 hours times $26.60 |
| Cost per hour at the phone | about $28.40 | $49,800 divided by 1,755 hours |
Recruiting sits outside that table because it arrives in lumps. SHRM's benchmark average cost per hire is nearly $4,700[4], and you pay it again each time the seat turns over; front desk turnover covers that side in detail.
Coverage: the hours nobody is at the desk
The table also shows what the money buys in time. The agency is open 42.5 hours a week. Across a full year, counting vacations, sick days, holidays and breaks, its receptionist is at the phone about 34 hours a week on average. Lunch is covered by whichever agent is free, which is often nobody.
168
hours in a week
42.5
hours the office is open
about 34
hours a week the receptionist is at the phone, averaged over a year
about 15
calls a week after 5:30 pm and on Saturdays, all to voicemail
Example figures for a fictional agency, rounded from the cost table above.
The evening calls are not random. In 2025, 81% of employed people worked on an average weekday[5], so many customers ring a business from a break at work or after they get home. Voicemail recovers some of those calls, but not reliably: in Pew's survey, 67% of adults said they let unknown numbers ring out and check for a voicemail, and 14% said they generally ignore voicemails as well[6]. Callbacks the next morning run into exactly that habit.
Measure the gap inside opening hours too, because it is easy to miss. For one week, have whoever answers note every call that rang out during lunch, breaks and the first busy half-hour of the morning. In this example office the count is small, about 10 calls a week, but each one is a client or prospect who reached nobody during the hours the agency says it is open. Add those to the after-hours pile and you have the slice that no amount of desk staffing on the current schedule will reach.
Cost per answered call, worked two ways
Example: of the 250 in-hours calls a week, say the receptionist answers 220, the agents pick up 20 while she is away and 10 reach voicemail. That is about 950 calls a month answered at the desk.
- Full-cost view, in this example: about $4,150 a month of employer cost divided by about 950 answered calls is roughly $4.36 a call. Use this view if the role exists mainly to answer phones.
- Phone-share view, in this example: at about 4 minutes a call including notes, the phone takes around 15 of her 37.5 desk hours in a normal week, close to 40%. That share of her cost, about $1,660 a month, works out to roughly $1.74 a call. Use this view if you would keep her anyway for payments, documents and the people who walk in.
The gap between $1.74 and $4.36 in this example is the whole argument in miniature. Software that takes routine calls off a receptionist who also runs the counter saves the phone share of her time, not her salary. Software that replaces a phone-only seat saves closer to the full cost. Most small offices are the first kind.
| Input | Example |
|---|---|
| Calls per working day | 50 |
| Minutes per call | 4 |
| Share of calls routine enough to hand off | 50% |
| Receptionist cost per hour worked | $26.60 |
| Calls a month | 1,085 |
| Staff hours on these calls | 72 |
| Hours handed off | 36 |
| Monthly value of that staff time | $962 |
How it is worked out: Calls a day × 21.7 working days × minutes per call ÷ 60 × share handled = hours; hours × hourly cost.
Assumptions
- Hourly cost of $26.60: the BLS median receptionist wage plus benefits at the June 2026 ratio for office and administrative support workers.[2]
- The 50 calls a weekday, 4 minutes a call and half of calls being routine (payments, ID cards, hours, claims numbers) are invented for this agency; use your own call log.
Example only: about 36 hours a month of receptionist time, roughly $960 at loaded cost, goes on calls simple enough to hand to software.
The AI side: a worksheet to fill from quotes
AI receptionist pricing varies by vendor and plan, so get it in writing and turn it into the same units as the table above. Four steps cover it.
Decide the slice
Overflow only, after hours only, or all day. In the example, overflow plus evenings and Saturdays is roughly 45 calls a week; all day is about 265.
Turn calls into minutes
Calls a week times average length times 4.33. In the example, at 3 minutes a call, the overflow slice is about 585 minutes a month and all day is about 3,440.
Price the quote at your volume
Monthly plan, included minutes or calls, the overage rate, set-up fees, extra numbers and contract length. Ask for the total at your real minutes, not the headline plan.
Add your own time
Writing the rules takes a few hours up front. Reading summaries is ongoing: in the example, 15 minutes a working day is about 5.4 hours a month, roughly $145 at $26.60 an hour.
Budget extra time for the first month. Expect to read every transcript in week one, fix the wording of a few answers, add the questions callers actually ask and tighten the rule for which calls go straight to an agent. That is the same breaking-in a new receptionist needs, just written down instead of learned at the desk, and it shrinks quickly once the answers settle.
Then compare like with like. For the overflow slice, set the monthly total against the value of the after-hours and missed calls it would answer, because a receptionist was never covering those hours. For an all-day setup, set it against the phone-share or full cost from the previous section, depending on whether the person stays. How AI receptionist pricing models work explains per-minute, per-call and flat plans in more detail.
Three setups, side by side
| Setup | Hours covered | What you pay for | Walk-ins and paperwork | Weak spot |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Receptionist only | About 34 a week on average; nights and Saturdays go to voicemail | About $49,800 a year in the example, plus hiring | Yes | Lunch, breaks, leave and every evening |
| Receptionist plus forwarding | Desk hours live; overflow, lunch and after hours forwarded | The same salary plus a service sized to the slice | Yes | Two things to manage and keep up to date |
| Forwarding only | Whatever hours you forward, up to all of them | A service sized to all calls, plus your review time | No | Nobody at the counter; complex calls still need a person |
The middle row is where most offices with in-person traffic land. In that setup an SI Employee takes the calls the desk cannot: it answers in the agency's name from information the owner approves, takes messages for agents, books appointments into a connected and tested calendar or records the request for staff to confirm, and transfers urgent calls to the number the agency chooses. If nobody picks up a transfer, the caller is told plainly and an urgent message is saved. Each call arrives as an email summary, with the recording and transcript in the account.
The family law example on this site, a four-attorney firm with one receptionist, models a quarter of calls arriving after 5 pm, which is the situation where the middle row earns its keep. For trades businesses, the plumbing guide to AI versus hiring another CSR runs the same decision for a dispatch office.
What the numbers leave out
- The counter. Payments in person, documents to sign, the client who drops in without calling. Software does none of it.
- Relationships. Long-standing clients who ask for the receptionist by name are a real asset; route them to her rather than through a script.
- Different mistakes. People mishear names and forget to pass messages on; software mishears and misreads requests in its own ways. Count both in a test rather than assuming either is error-free.
- Caller attitudes. In a 2025 Pew survey, 50% of adults said they were more concerned than excited about the growing use of AI in daily life[7]. Say plainly that the caller is speaking with an automated assistant and make it easy to reach a person.
- Vacancies. When a receptionist leaves, coverage drops to zero until the next hire is trained. A forwarded slice keeps running.
- Peaks. Several calls at once around opening time is common in a busy office. Ask any vendor how many calls it answers at the same moment, and ask your receptionist how often she has a caller on hold.
Put the pieces together and the decision is rarely human or AI. It is how many hours of live, in-person cover you need, and what the cheapest reliable way is to answer everything outside them. If the answer is fewer desk hours, a part-time receptionist may cover the in-person block. If the answer is no desk at all, SI Employee or a new hire walks through that call. Either way, prove it on your own calls first with the two-week test in is an AI receptionist worth it.
Run the same comparison on your own office
- Pull a month of calls and split them into desk hours, lunch and breaks, and after hours.
- Cost your receptionist per hour worked: wage plus benefits, using your payroll reports or the office-support ratio above.
- Work out cost per answered call both ways, full cost and phone share, and decide honestly which one applies.
- Get two written quotes priced at your real minutes for the slice you would forward, and add your review time.
- Put the quote next to the value of the calls nobody answers today, then test the cheapest option that covers them.
That last step matters more than the spreadsheet. A cost comparison tells you whether an option can pay; only your own calls tell you whether it works. Keep the receptionist's log running through any test, so the before and after are measured the same way. The employer-cost side of this worksheet is laid out line by line in the true cost of an employee.
Frequently asked questions
Is an AI receptionist cheaper than a human receptionist?
It depends on what it replaces. A full-time receptionist on the median wage costs the employer about $49,800 a year in the example, but software that only takes routine calls off a receptionist who also runs the counter saves the phone share of her time, not her salary. Compare both against the same calls and hours.
What does a human receptionist cost per call?
In the example, between about $1.74 and $4.36 an answered call, depending on whether you count her whole cost or only the share of her time spent on the phone. Divide your own monthly employer cost by answered calls to get the full-cost figure.
Can an AI receptionist replace a receptionist completely?
For a phone-only office with no walk-ins, sometimes. Where there is a counter, documents or payments in person, it usually covers overflow, lunch and after hours while a person handles the desk. Will AI replace receptionists looks at this in more depth.
What costs of an AI receptionist are easy to miss?
Overage minutes at your real call volume, set-up fees, extra numbers, contract length, and your own time to write the rules, read summaries and update information when hours or services change.
Should I count benefits when comparing costs?
Yes. For office and administrative support workers, benefits added about 46% on top of wages per hour worked in June 2026[2]. Comparing a software fee with the wage alone understates the human side.
References
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). Receptionists: Occupational Outlook Handbook (Pay) (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Employer Costs for Employee Compensation, Table 4: private industry workers by occupational and industry group, June 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Paid leave benefits: Average number of sick and vacation days by length of service requirement (opens in a new tab) ↑
Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM) (2022). The Real Costs of Recruitment (opens in a new tab) ↑
U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2025). American Time Use Survey: 2025 Results (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑
Pew Research Center (2025). How Americans View AI and Its Impact on People and Society (opens in a new tab) ↑