Skip to content

Cost, ROI and Staffing

Call Answering ROI: A Calculator You Can Fill In Tonight

Work out call answering ROI from numbers you already have: calls, missed share, close rate, job value and margin, with a filled-in example and calculator.

AssistCall research teamPublished Reviewed by Faruque Amin, VP of Sales and Marketing9 min read

On this page
  1. Six numbers, all of which you already have
  2. Step one: the revenue behind unanswered calls
  3. Step two: turn revenue into return
  4. Step three: set the gain against a quote
  5. Adjusting the inputs for your kind of business
  6. Returns the formula leaves out
  7. Keep the number honest after you decide
  8. Frequently asked questions
  9. References
Cost, ROI and Staffing: Call Answering ROI: A Calculator You Can Fill In Tonight57%: of small employer firms named reaching customers and growing sales as a challenge in 2024COST, ROI AND STAFFINGCall Answering ROI: ACalculator You Can Fill InTonight57%of small employer firms named reaching customers and growingsales as a challenge in 2024AssistCallInsightsCost, ROI and Staffing: Call Answering ROI: A Calculator You Can Fill In Tonight57%: of small employer firms named reaching customers and growing sales as a challenge in 2024COST, ROI AND STAFFINGCall Answering ROI: ACalculator You CanFill In Tonight57%of small employer firms named reachingcustomers and growing sales as achallenge in 2024AssistCall
Figure source: Federal Reserve Banks (Small Business Credit Survey), 2024[1]

Key takeaways

  • Six inputs decide call answering ROI: calls a week, missed share, new-customer share, close rate, average job value and gross margin. All of them are in your phone log, invoices and books.
  • Count profit, not revenue, and give credit for the callers you already win back by calling them back.
  • In the electrical contractor example, answering the calls that ring out today is worth about $3,150 a month in gross profit and staff time.
  • That figure is the most any answering option can cost before it loses money; ROI is the gain divided by the quote you actually receive.

Six numbers, all of which you already have

Most owners can work out what answering the phone is worth in under an hour, at the kitchen table, from records they already keep. The trick is to stop treating it as a feeling about missed calls and run it as an investment: what you gain each month, what it costs, and the ratio between them. Reaching customers was the most common operational challenge small employer firms reported in 2024[1], and the phone is where many of those customers try first.

You need six inputs. Pull them in this order, because each one is easier once you have the one before.

Where to find each input tonight, with the example values used below
InputWhere to find itExample valueCommon mistake
Calls a weekYour carrier's or phone system's call history; export four weeks and divide by four45Including outbound calls and internal transfers
Share missedSame export: calls that rang out or went to voicemail22%Counting a call answered on a second extension as missed
Share from new customersMatch the missed numbers against your customer list45%Guessing instead of checking; spam inflates the count
Close rateNew-customer calls answered last month that turned into a booked job45%Borrowing a rate from another channel, such as web forms
Average job valueInvoices to new customers over the last three to six months$1,000Letting one very large job pull the average up; use the median if so
Gross marginYour profit and loss: revenue minus materials and direct labor, as a share of revenue45%Stopping at revenue, when materials and labor come out of every job

If you have never checked your average job value against anything outside your own books, public data gives a sanity check. Median homeowner spending in 2021 to 2023 ran from $500 for plumbing fixture work to $10,000 for roofing[2]. A general dentist in solo practice billed a median of $480.75 per visit in 2025[3], and AAA put the average car repair bill at $500 to $600[4]. If your number is far from your industry's benchmark, find out why before trusting the ROI.

Median homeowner spending per project, 2021 to 2023Rounded to the nearest $100; a sanity check for home services job values.
Median homeowner spending per project, 2021 to 2023Bar chart. Plumbing fixtures: $500; Water heater, dishwasher or disposal: $800; Electrical wiring or fuse boxes: $1,000; Doors and windows: $2,800; HVAC: $5,500; Roofing: $10,000.Plumbing fixturesPlumbing fixtures: $500$500Water heater, dishwasher or disposalWater heater, dishwasher or disposal: $800$800Electrical wiring or fuse boxesElectrical wiring or fuse boxes: $1,000$1,000Doors and windowsDoors and windows: $2,800$2,800HVACHVAC: $5,500$5,500RoofingRoofing: $10,000$10,000Median homeowner spending per project, 2021 to 2023Bar chart. Plumbing fixtures: $500; Water heater, dishwasher or disposal: $800; Electrical wiring or fuse boxes: $1,000; Doors and windows: $2,800; HVAC: $5,500; Roofing: $10,000.Plumbing fixturesPlumbing fixtures: $500$500Water heater, dishwasher or disposalWater heater, dishwasher or disposal: $800$800Electrical wiring or fuse boxesElectrical wiring or fuse boxes: $1,000$1,000Doors and windowsDoors and windows: $2,800$2,800HVACHVAC: $5,500$5,500RoofingRoofing: $10,000$10,000

Source: U.S. Census Bureau and U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, 2023[2]

Show the data
ItemValue
Plumbing fixtures$500
Water heater, dishwasher or disposal$800
Electrical wiring or fuse boxes$1,000
Doors and windows$2,800
HVAC$5,500
Roofing$10,000

Step one: the revenue behind unanswered calls

Example: a fictional residential electrical contractor with three electricians and an office manager. The office answers well in the morning, but from about 11 am the manager is out at supply houses or on site visits two or three days a week, and after 4:30 the phone goes to voicemail. The four-week export gives the inputs in the table above.

Example: a month of calls at the fictional electrical contractor
  1. 195

    calls in a month

  2. 43

    rang out or went to voicemail

  3. 19

    of those were new customers

  4. about 9

    would have booked a job if answered

  5. $8,680

    of work behind those calls

Example figures, rounded from the calculator below.

ExampleExample: work behind unanswered new-customer calls at a fictional electrical contractor
Example: worked figures
InputExample
Calls per week45
Calls that go unanswered (%)22%
Share of missed calls from new customers45%
Share of answered new callers who book45%
Average first job$1,000
Unanswered calls a month43
From new customers19
Bookings that would have followed8.7
Monthly value at risk$8,681

How it is worked out: Calls a week × 4.33 weeks × unanswered share × new-customer share × booking rate × average value.

Assumptions

  • Average first job of $1,000: the American Housing Survey median homeowner spend on electrical wiring or fuse box projects in 2021 to 2023.[2]
  • The 45 weekly calls, 22% unanswered, 45% new customers and 45% close rate are invented for this contractor; replace them with your own four-week export.

Example only: about $8,680 a month of work sits behind calls that ring out today. This is revenue, not yet return; the next steps turn it into profit.

The calculator is deliberately simple: calls a week, times 4.33 weeks, times each share in turn, times the job value. Its weakest input is usually the close rate, because owners remember the calls that booked and forget the ones that did not. If you are unsure, lower it by ten points and see whether the answer still holds.

Then test how much each input matters. Because the model multiplies the inputs, a ten-point error in any share moves the answer in proportion, so the useful question is which inputs you are least sure of. The table runs the example with one input lower at a time, all the way through to monthly gain after margin, callback credit and staff time.

Example: how the electrical contractor's monthly gain moves when one input is lower
Change from the exampleWork behind missed callsMonthly gain
None (example as above)$8,680$3,150
Close rate 35% instead of 45%$6,751$2,498
Missed share 15% instead of 22%$5,918$2,217
New-customer share 35% instead of 45%$6,751$2,498
Average first job $800 instead of $1,000$6,944$2,564

In this example, even the most pessimistic single change leaves a monthly gain above $2,200. If your own version falls apart when one input drops by ten points, the case is thin, and a short test on real calls is worth more than a better spreadsheet.

Step two: turn revenue into return

Revenue is not return. In the example, three adjustments turn the $8,680 into a number you can compare with a cost.

  1. Apply your gross margin

    Materials, direct labor and fuel are spent on every job you win. At an example 45% margin, $8,680 of work is about $3,906 of gross profit.

  2. Credit the callbacks you already make

    Some missed callers are reached later and book anyway. If your log shows you win back one in four, take 25% off: about $2,930 in this example.

  3. Add staff time

    Voicemail and phone tag eat office hours. In this example, 6 hours a month at $36.73, the BLS average employer cost per hour worked for office and administrative support staff[5], adds about $220.

  4. Total the monthly gain

    About $3,150 a month for the example contractor. This is the most an answering option can cost before it loses money.

Be honest about the callback credit, because it is where most ROI estimates go wrong in both directions. Callbacks recover less than owners expect: in Pew's survey, 67% of adults said they let unknown numbers ring and check for a voicemail, and 14% said they generally ignore voicemails too[6]. On the other hand, a business that returns every call within ten minutes will win back more than one that calls back the next morning. Use your own log: of last month's missed new-customer calls, how many did you reach, and how many booked?

The staff-time line uses the office-support average of $36.73 per hour worked[5] only because the example has no payroll of its own. Use your own employer cost per hour, or the owner's hour if the owner is the one playing phone tag. Value your hour shows how to price that.

Step three: set the gain against a quote

Now get prices for the ways you could answer those calls: a part-time hire for the afternoon, overtime, an answering service, or an SI Employee on the forwarded line. Whoever answers, the arithmetic is the same:

  • Monthly ROI = (monthly gain minus monthly cost) divided by monthly cost.
  • Break-even cost = the monthly gain. In the example, any option costing less than about $3,150 a month pays for itself on these assumptions.
  • Payback on set-up = one-off costs, including your own hours writing instructions and testing, divided by the monthly gain minus the monthly cost.
Example: the ROI worksheet for the fictional electrical contractor; fill the last two lines from your own quote
LineExampleHow it is worked out
Work behind missed new-customer calls$8,680 a monthCalculator above
Gross profit on that work$3,906Times 45% gross margin
After callback credit$2,930Less 25% already won back
Staff time recovered$2206 hours at $36.73[5]
Monthly gain$3,150Break-even cost
Monthly cost of the optionFrom your quoteInclude overage and extra numbers
Monthly ROIGain minus cost, divided by costA cost of a quarter of the gain gives 300%

Compare options on the same calls. A part-timer from noon to 5 covers the midday gap but not the evenings; an after-hours service covers the evenings but not the midday trips to the supply house. The option with the best ROI is often the one that covers the hours your log shows the misses, not the cheapest one. Software payback period goes further into set-up costs and contract length.

Adjusting the inputs for your kind of business

The six inputs work for almost any business that sells over the phone, but they behave differently by business type. A few adjustments keep the answer realistic:

  • Appointment businesses such as dental offices, clinics and salons: use the value of a first appointment, keep the close rate high, and check capacity before counting every booking, because a full book cannot take more first visits.
  • High-ticket, low-close work such as roofing, remodeling and legal matters: one booked job can swing a month, so take inputs from three to six months of data rather than four weeks, and use the median job value.
  • Emergency trades such as plumbing, heating and locksmiths: split the calls by hour first. Evening and weekend calls can carry a different mix of urgent jobs and new customers than daytime calls, so they belong in their own run of the calculator.
  • Businesses with many small orders such as restaurants and repair counters: the job value is small and the call count is large, so the staff-time line often outweighs recovered sales. Count minutes on the phone before counting orders.

Whatever the business, keep a note of where each number came from and the date you pulled it. Next quarter's rerun is only useful if it is measured the same way, and AI answering service for small business shows how to score options on the same set of test calls.

Returns the formula leaves out

The calculator counts one job per new customer. Three things make the real return larger, and it is worth knowing them even if you leave them out of the headline number to stay conservative.

  • Repeat work. A homeowner who books an outlet repair this month may call for a panel upgrade next year. Customer lifetime value for service businesses shows how to put a figure on it.
  • Advertising performance. Google's Local Services Ads ranking takes responsiveness into account, and Google says missed calls may count against it[7]. If you pay for leads, unanswered calls cost you twice.
  • Owner attention. Fewer voicemails to clear at 7 pm is not on any invoice, but it decides whether the owner spends the evening quoting jobs or returning calls.

And one thing makes it smaller: capacity. If your crews are booked three weeks out, answering more calls lengthens the queue rather than adding jobs. Check the schedule before counting every booked call as new revenue.

Keep the number honest after you decide

Treat tonight's figure as an estimate of what is at stake, not a forecast. It tells you how much answering the missed calls could be worth and the most you should pay to do it. Whether a given option actually wins those calls is something only your own calls can show.

Whatever you choose, rerun the six inputs once a month for the first quarter. The missed share should fall, the close rate should hold, and the monthly gain should land near the estimate. If you forward calls to an answering setup, its records make this easier: with an SI Employee, each call arrives as an email summary, with the recording and transcript kept in the account, so you can count new-customer calls and bookings directly instead of reconstructing them from a carrier export.

  1. Export the month's calls and recount missed and new-customer shares.
  2. Count bookings from new-customer calls, by source if you can.
  3. Check average first-job value against the previous quarter.
  4. Note anything that changed outside the phones, such as a price rise or a slow season, before crediting the answering option with it.

The plumbing after-hours example runs the same kind of model for evening and weekend calls at a five-truck company, and the home services guide to what missed calls cost has trade-specific inputs for HVAC, electrical and roofing. If the result says answering pays, the next question is what a missed seat at the desk costs when someone leaves, covered in front desk turnover, and whether to prove it with a two-week test first, as in is an AI receptionist worth it.

Frequently asked questions

What is a good ROI for answering calls?

Any positive monthly ROI on conservative inputs is a good sign, because the formula leaves out repeat work. If the result only turns positive with your most optimistic close rate and job value, treat it as unproven and test on a slice of calls first.

Should I use revenue or profit in the ROI?

Profit. Multiply the work behind missed calls by your gross margin. At the example's 45% margin, using revenue would overstate the return more than twofold.

How do I find my missed-call rate?

Export four weeks of call history from your carrier or phone system and count calls that rang out or went to voicemail as a share of all inbound calls. The missed call audit walks through it in an afternoon.

Does this work for appointment businesses, not just trades?

Yes. Swap the job value for the value of a first appointment, such as a first visit or a consultation, and count rebooking separately as repeat work.

How often should I recalculate?

Monthly for the first quarter after any change, then at each season change. A heating contractor's January numbers say little about April.

References

  1. Federal Reserve Banks (Small Business Credit Survey) (2024). 2025 Report on Employer Firms: Findings from the 2024 Small Business Credit Survey (opens in a new tab) ↑

  2. U.S. Census Bureau and U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (2023). Home Improvements (2023 American Housing Survey infographic) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  3. American Dental Association Health Policy Institute (2025). Income, Gross Billings, Expenses, Characteristics, Selected Staff Wages: Selected 2025 Results from the Survey of Dental Practice (Table 9) (opens in a new tab) ↑

  4. AAA Newsroom (2017). One-in-Three U.S. Drivers Cannot Pay for an Unexpected Car Repair Bill (opens in a new tab) ↑

  5. U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (2026). Employer Costs for Employee Compensation, Table 4: private industry workers by occupational and industry group, June 2026 (opens in a new tab) ↑

  6. Pew Research Center (2020). Most Americans don't answer cellphone calls from unknown numbers (opens in a new tab) ↑

  7. Google (2026). About ad rankings (Local Services Ads Help) (opens in a new tab) ↑

Book a demo

Meet your SI Employee.

Book a short demo. We walk through calls like yours and show what your SI Employee would answer, book and follow up.

Book a demo